By John W. Schiemann

Whilst the Senate published its so-called "Torture record" in December 2014 the area could study that, for years, the CIA had used unimaginably brutal how to interrogate its prisoners - usually with out yielding any worthy or fair details. The employer had lengthy and adamantly defended its use of torture, staunchly arguing that it was once not just simply yet priceless for the country's defense. or even amid the revelations of the document, questions abound approximately even if torture may be thought of a justifiable instrument of nationwide defense.

Is interrogational torture a good approach to extracting info? How reliable does the data extracted must be for the torture to be thought of profitable? How usually or how vigorously needs to torture be used to accomplish invaluable info? it can be the case that interrogational torture can by no means be justified below any situations, yet, in keeping with John Schiemann, whether it is to be justified in any respect, it needs to be potent. in line with a couple of nationwide ballot, so much american citizens do think that torture can paintings, and that it may be justified lower than sure conditions. but when the data that torturers extract is undesirable, then the strategy quantities to not anything greater than natural sadism. So, how do we remedy the obstacle over no matter if to torture or to not torture?

In this e-book, John Schiemann takes a really new angle to the query of torture: online game conception. contemplating torture as a "game" performed among an interrogator and a detainee, the booklet walks the reader throughout the good judgment of interrogational torture, evaluating the results to the claims made through torture proponents. The booklet attracts on a large choice of assets starting from documents of the Inquisition to mystery CIA memos to track this good judgment, illustrating each one consequence of the version with a story from the true international of interrogational torture. Does Torture Work? is an soaking up and provocative tackle one in every of so much mentioned human rights and protection dilemmas of our time.

Show description

Read or Download Does Torture Work? PDF

Similar intelligence & espionage books

US Elite Forces – Vietnam

Книга US Elite Forces - Vietnam US Elite Forces - Vietnam Книги Вооружение Автор: Leroy Thompson Год издания: 1985 Формат: pdf Издат. :SquadronSignal guides, inc. Страниц: fifty one Размер: eighty Язык: Английский0 (голосов: zero) Оценка:Книга описываетвнешний вид, униформу, образцы оружия, которым пользовались подразделения специального назначения США во Вьетнаме.

Partly Cloudy: Ethics in War, Espionage, Covert Action, and Interrogation (Scarecrow Professional Intelligence Education)

Partially Cloudy: Ethics in struggle, Espionage, Covert activities, and Interrogation explores a few wrenching moral matters and demanding situations confronted by way of our army and intelligence body of workers. David L. Perry presents a powerful and useful method of interpreting moral matters in battle and intelligence operations and applies cautious reasoning to problems with important value this present day, resembling the query of torture in interrogating detainees, utilizing espionage to penetrate adversarial regimes and terrorist cells, mounting covert motion to undermine their strength, utilizing discrimination and proportionality in army operations, fending off atrocities in strive against and counterinsurgency, and cultivating ethical knowledge.

Sniper Rifles: From the 19th to the 21st Century (Osprey Weapon)

A technical define of the background of the sniper rifle, from its advent in struggle throughout the Napoleonic wars, during the US Civil conflict to its present apogee because the most often used wrestle rifle in Iraq and Afghanistan. This ebook information the advance of ammunition, assorted guns forms together with unmarried shot, journal loading and semi-automatic, in addition to the advent and use of optical attractions.

United States of Jihad: Investigating America’s Homegrown Terrorists

A riveting, panoramic examine “homegrown” Islamist terrorism from 9-11 to the current   for the reason that Sep 11, greater than 300 Americans—born and raised in Minnesota, Alabama, New Jersey, and elsewhere—have been indicted or convicted of terrorism fees. a few have taken the struggle out of the country: an American was once between those that deliberate the assaults in Mumbai, and greater than 80 U.

Additional info for Does Torture Work?

Example text

Once Navarro was secured to the bench, Yuki put a cloth on Navarro’s face and began pouring water from a nearby faucet on Navarro’s face. The stream of water continued until Navarro lost consciousness. The process was then repeated four or five times over the next two hours. ” When Yuki discovered the lie, he repeated the procedure on Navarro another two or three times. Captain Chase Nielsen, a B-25 navigator, had provided nothing but his name, rank, and serial number to his Japanese interrogator on the afternoon of April 24, 1942.

Even our own military considered them torture less than a decade before 9/11. S. Army Field Manual classified 32 DOES TORTURE WORK? several of these techniques (“infliction of pain through . . bondage,” “forcing an individual to stand, sit, or kneel in abnormal positions for prolonged periods of time,” “any form of beating”) as “physical torture” and others (“food” and “sleep deprivation”) as “mental torture” and expressly forbid their use, arguing that “the use of force is a poor technique, as it yields unreliable results, may damage subsequent collection efforts, and can induce the source to say whatever he thinks the interrogator wants to hear” (Department of the Army 1992, pp.

Does torture work? ”9 This commonplace idea that torture eventually works on everyone, the gut feeling that there is only so much any human can withstand, is an instance of what we might call the dangerous seduction of intuition. It is seductive because it seems so self-evidently obvious. It is dangerous because it can nevertheless be wrong. After all, Senator John McCain gave up no useful information to his North Vietnamese captors; he just provided the names of the Green Bay Packers offensive line as fellow members of his squadron and the names of cities that had already been bombed as supposed future targets (Salter and McCain 1999, p.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.56 of 5 – based on 43 votes